What to Do When You Hire a 'Bad Egg': A Comprehensive Guide for Founders and CEOs

​

Hiring the wrong person can be a costly mistake for any business, but it can be especially damaging for startups and small businesses. When you're operating on a tight budget and every employee plays a critical role, a bad hire can derail your progress and even threaten your survival.

​

If you find yourself in the unfortunate position of having hired a 'bad egg', it's important to take swift and decisive action. The longer you wait to address the issue, the more damage they can do to your team and your business.

​

Step 1: Identify the Problem

​

The first step is to identify the specific behaviours or performance issues that are causing concern. This could include:

​

• Poor performance or lack of productivity
• Negative attitude or lack of motivation
• Conflict with other team members
• Dishonesty or unethical behaviour
• Violation of company policies

​

Step 2: Gather Evidence

​

Once you have identified the problem, it's important to gather evidence to support your claims. This could include:

​

• Performance reviews or other documentation of poor performance
• Emails or other communication that demonstrates negative behaviour
• Witness statements from other team members

​

Step 3: Confront the Employee

​

Once you have gathered your evidence, it's time to confront the employee. Be direct and specific about the concerns you have, and provide examples to support your claims.

​

It's important to be professional and respectful during this conversation, even if the employee is defensive or hostile. Remember, your goal is to resolve the issue and improve the employee's performance, not to humiliate or punish them.

​

Step 4: Develop a Performance Improvement Plan (PIP)

​

If you believe that the employee has the potential to improve, you may want to develop a performance improvement plan (PIP). A PIP is a formal agreement between you and the employee that outlines the specific goals and expectations that they need to meet in order to remain employed.

​

The PIP should be clear, specific, and measurable. It should also include a timeline for improvement and consequences for failure to meet expectations.

​

Step 5: Monitor Progress

​

Once you have implemented a PIP, it's important to monitor the employee's progress closely. Meet with them regularly to discuss their progress and provide feedback.

​

If the employee is not making satisfactory progress, you may need to consider further disciplinary action, up to and including termination of employment.

​

Step 6: Terminate Employment (If Necessary)

​

If the employee is unable or unwilling to improve their performance, you may need to terminate their employment. This should be done in a professional and legal manner.

​

Be sure to provide the employee with written notice of termination and explain the reasons for their dismissal. You should also offer them a severance package, if appropriate.

​

Tips for Avoiding Bad Hires

​

The best way to avoid hiring a 'bad egg' is to have a thorough hiring process in place. Here are a few tips:

​

• Screen candidates carefully. Use a combination of interviews, reference checks, and background checks to assess candidates' skills, experience, and character.
• Trust your instincts. If you have a bad feeling about a candidate, don't ignore it.
• Hire for culture fit. Make sure that candidates are a good fit for your company culture and values.
• Provide clear expectations. Once you have hired an employee, make sure that they understand their roles and responsibilities.
• Monitor performance regularly. Meet with employees regularly to discuss their progress and provide feedback.

​

Conclusion

​

Hiring a 'bad egg' can be a frustrating and costly experience. However, by following the steps outlined in this article, you can minimise the damage and get your business back on track.

​

Remember, it's important to be decisive and take action as soon as you identify a problem. The longer you wait, the more damage the employee can do to your team and your business.